Well, it took a while, but I found a suitably bizarre picture for todays blog post haha.
I was perusing Sherdog's (www.sherdog.com) grappling forum and came across an interesting thread about what you would pick if you could have any of the best grapplers strengths. Some people answered that they would want Marcelo Garcias guillotine choke, some answered Rodolfo Vieras Guard passing, and others answered that they would want Roger Gracie's defensive and escaping skills. That's what I would pick as well. As per usual, there were people who disagreed with this point, and I thought about posting my argument on there, but figured it would be more useful here.
Why I am a big fan of spending time on defense and escapes in grappling:
1. Because no matter what mindset you adopt for grappling (the mind set of the masses usually reflects whatever the current "hot" grappler espouses in interviews), there is always someone that is going to control you and force you to go places that you do not want to go. A lot of people feel that having an aggressive, taking the initiative type of game is best. I agree, I like to get one step ahead and stay there if I can, however, since I am not a perfect grappler, I'm often forced to play differently.
2. Because I have competed against and rolled with some really really good grapplers. I've had my ass whupped a bunch of times. I have been put in bad positions plenty of times and I have escaped plenty of times. The reason? Because I do lots of positional sparring from bad positions. I have supreme confidence that I will survive and escape any bad position. While there are times that I am wrong and have to tap, I believe that practicing my defense and escapes gives me the confidence to stay calm under pressure and not be forced to make stupid mistakes. The nature of mistakes is that they multiply and spiral out of control quickly. You make one mistake and get your guard passed, you lose your cool freaking out trying to escape and get your back taken. You panic because someone is on your back and leave your neck open. You get choked. I think confidence, calmness and a clear and well practiced knowledge of defense and escapes can halt this downward spiral.
3. This is one of the most important reasons for me. Brazilian Jiujitsu is a constantly evolving sport/art. There are constant innovations, new guards, new grips, tricks, transitions, sweeps, etc...it's impossible to know everything and it's impossible to get good at everything. It's even very hard to keep up with how fast some new innovations are developing. The thing is that while there are constant innovations in the game, the basic positional structure of Brazilian Jiujitsu remains the same. All roads lead to positional dominance and submission.
Take berimbolo for example. This is a guard that is wildly popular now because of the Mendes brothers, Samuel Braga and other innovators in the lighter weight classes. It's a super hard position to deconstruct (you can see my attempts in my last post) and shut down. It begins with grips and takes you into a confusing and seemingly complex series of transitions, inversions and controlled scrambling movements. It ends, however with someone either on top of you in side mount , or with someone on our back. Both completely familiar positions in Brazilian Jiujitsu for decades now. 50/50 guard is the same, spider guard is the same, leg drag pass is the same, tornado guard is the same, inverted guard is the same. For the majority of innovations, you will either end up on bottom of side mount, mount, or with someone on your back positionally. Submission wise, you will end up either in an armbar, triangle, omo plata ankle lock or with someone applying a lapel choke from the back. Of course this is a simplification and there are other possible submissions, but those are the majority of things that you have to worry about. Now, if you simplify it further you could even lump triangle, omo plata, armbar all into one group. This is a manageable amount of things to practice.
There will always be a sweep that catches you off guard. There will always be some slick guard pass that shuts you down with almost embarrassing ease. There will always be someone who is better than you or stronger than you and just shuts you down and makes you play their game. For the most part, while you might not know the road they are taking you down, you will most likely know the destination once you get there.
4. No one gets any younger. Not even with plastic surgery and tasty chewable vitamins. I want to grapple in some form for the rest of my life, or at least until someone invents something that I think is even more awesome. :) Now, I am 32. I can grapple fairly well some days and I can do well against people bigger, stronger, younger than me because I am fit, flexible and reasonably strong (thanks to my buddy Jason C. Brown). When I am 40, I can reasonably expect some of my abilities to decline. When I am 50 I think this will be more pronounced. I will probably have better technique and understand my game much better at those ages, but I won't be able to get away with some of the stuff that my youth affords me. I may not always be able to bend my legs in crazy ways without getting hurt, etc... There will come a time when my 20 year old students and friends are smashing me on the mat. You cannot always be the hammer, so to speak. Defense and escapes will be my greatest ally in those times and I'm sure I will find it more and more valuable as time goes on.
5. Coming full circle, I think that defensive and refined escaping abilities allows you to play an aggressive game more effectively. When you are forced out of your game, you cannot play one step ahead until you defend the threats and escape. Once you escape, you can sometimes get the jump on your opponent and start off one step ahead. For example. You get stuck on bottom of side mount. It's really hard to attack anything from there. You have to escape, but your opponent is threatening chokes. You turn your back and they start to take your back. You defend your collar and start to scoot your hips out. You manage to get one step ahead while escaping and get to top of half guard. You seize this initiative and run with it, passing their half guard to get on top of side mount where you quickly begin your attacks. A situation reversed. The tables turned. You want to "go first". You want to be one step ahead and push your game or "impose your will" as people like to say. But when you cannot do this you cannot crumble, you have to be able to marshal your forces and weather the storm. If you suck at defense and escapes, then you can be a black belt or whatever advanced grappling title you choose, but when you come across someone who can get past your game, then it's check mate. If you work your defense and escapes, there is always a fighting chance.
So for me, if I could pick any one thing that I would like to "absorb" from the best grapplers, I would pick Roger Gracie's defensive and escaping abilities.